The Best Menthol E-Liquids
I have preferred menthol e-liquids as long as I have used electronic cigarettes; I find the intense rush of menthol to be very satisfying for my nicotine cravings, and feel that the best menthol e-liquids represent everything that is great about e-cigs. Because I have reviewed so many menthol e-liquids that browsing every full review on eDripping.com can be time-consuming, I have put together this brief comparison describing the strengths, flavor notes and relative menthol levels of each one. Click a link or picture to display the product page for that e-liquid.
| Product | Picture | Description | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Volcano Menthol Burst |  |
Menthol Burst is the first e-liquid I have tried that really lives up to its claim of providing a truly intense menthol experience. Has a very high level of menthol and a neutral mint flavor that mixes well with other e-liquids. | 5.000 |
| eLiquid Planet Essence Ice |  |
Essence Ice has a base flavor of tobacco, at times resembling the taste of an unlit premium cigar. Has a medium level of menthol and a smooth menthol tobacco flavor. | 4.625 |
| Virgin Vapor Peppermint Chill |  |
Peppermint Chill uses natural peppermint to create a flavor that strongly resembles real mint tea. Combined with a nice helping of menthol, this is a great mint e-liquid that doesn’t taste like a candy cane. | 4.375 |
| Halo Menthol Ice |  |
Menthol Ice has a base flavor of tobacco with a hint of mint and a medium level of menthol. Smooth and mellow menthol e-liquid. | 4.250 |
| eLiquid Plannet Essence NPT (Newport) |  |
NPT is a spicy, dry e-liquid with flavors of pepper, cinnamon and clove. Low menthol, plenty of throat hit. | 4.125 |
| Halo Malibu Menthol |  |
Malibu Menthol has flavor notes of pineapple and coconut over a medium menthol base. Produces massive amounts of vapor and isn’t overly sweet. | 4.000 |
| Halo Mystic Menthol |  |
High to very high level of menthol with a slight neutral peppermint flavor. | 3.875 |
| Halo Kringle’s Curse |  |
High menthol and strong peppermint flavor without a lot of sweetness. | 3.750 |
| Ares Menthol Additive |  |
Not a menthol e-liquid, but rather an additive that adds menthol to e-liquids with a few drops. Works well, but could be more powerful. | 3.750 |
| Mister-E-Liquid Menthol |  |
High to very high menthol with a base flavor of tobacco smoke. Tastes a bit like a menthol cigarette, but the smoke flavor might be an irritant for long-term electronic cigarette users. | 3.500 |
| Halo TruePure |  |
TruePure has a base flavor of peppermint with a hint of tobacco. A slightly less sweet, more intense experience than Halo’s CoolMist. Low to medium menthol. | 3.500 |
| Intellicig ECOpure Menthol |  |
ECOpure Menthol uses a nicotine extraction that is 99.82% pure and completely propylene glycol-free, giving it a smooth, neutral and slightly sweet flavor. Unfortunately, it has very little menthol. | 3.500 |
| V2 Cigs Menthol |  |
High menthol for a small cartridge. Interesting combination of peppermint and tobacco flavors but tastes very artificial. | 3.250 |
| Halo CoolMist |  |
CoolMist is a mix of mint flavors including peppermint, spearmint and wintergreen with a low to medium level of menthol. A very sweet dessert e-liquid that reminds me of a pillow mint. | 3.250 |
| Johnson Creek Arctic Menthol |  |
Arctic Menthol is a mix of tobacco and mint flavors somewhat resembling Nat Sherman’s discontinued Hint of Mint cigarette. Low menthol. | 3.250 |
| eLiquid Planet Menthol |  |
eLiquid Planet’s standard Menthol e-liquid has a base flavor of mint and a medium to high level of menthol. Slight chemical aftertaste. | 3.000 |
| Johnson Creek Wisconsin Frost |  |
A mix of peppermint and artificial smoke flavors with a low amount of menthol. Very harsh. | 2.875 |
| deejStuff deejBlend 05 Menthol |  |
High menthol with a base flavor that resembles smoke more closely than tobacco. Intended to resemble the “Marlboro Menthol” brand. A bit too bright and harsh for me but may be a good choice for people who have tried several menthol e-liquids and hated them all. | 2.625 |
| Gourmet Vapor Menthol Madness |  |
High menthol from a variety of different mentholated flavor components. The eucalyptus flavor is nice but a little strange. | 2.500 |
| Smoke Revolution USA Menthol Crush |  |
Low menthol. Dry and a bit harsh. Strong artificial peppermint flavor and tobacco scent. | 2.500 |
| Johnson Creek Tundra |  |
Tundra is a mix of tobacco and mint flavors with a very low amount of menthol. Bitter and harsh. | 2.125 |
| Halo Tiki Juice |  |
Tiki Juice has a mix of tobacco and fruit flavors including cinnamon, clove, pineapple, nutmeg and cherry. The flavor mix clashes a bit, and the e-liquid has very little menthol. | 1.875 |
| Volcano Menthol |  |
Volcano Menthol e-liquid has a base flavor of tobacco and a low level of menthol. I found the flavor unpleasant and overly sweet. | 1.875 |
| Ares Menthol Tobacco |  |
Low to medium menthol over a sweet tobacco base that resembles butterscotch. I found the flavor a bit unpleasant. | 1.875 |
| Gourmet Vapor Menthol Eucalyptus |  |
Tastes like a plain white cough drop. Very uninteresting flavor and too little menthol. | 1.625 |
| Virgin Vapor Menthol Moon Drops |  |
Menthol Moon Drops is a flavorless menthol e-liquid intended primarily for mixing. Unfortunately, it has far too little menthol to be of any use in a diluted state. | 1.500 |
| Vapure Dry Blend Menthol |  |
Very little menthol, and a taste that reminds me of cheap, harsh drug store perfume. | 1.250 |
| Safe Cig Menthol Cartomizer |  |
A horrible chemical aftertaste ruins this interesting mix of tobacco and peppermint flavors. | 1.125 |
| Volcano Menthol (Discontinued) |  |
Volcano’s original menthol e-liquid had a base flavor of mint and a high level of menthol. Volcano replaced this e-liquid with Menthol Burst after switching to a new USA-based supplier. | 0.000 |
